Named First Team Class 1A All-OVAC Softball for 2025 were Paden City’s Riley Blake and Valley’s Maddy Campbell. Second Team Class 1A was Lakynn Billiter of Paden City and Michaela Miller of Valley.

First Team Class 2A All-OVAC Softball for 2025 were Jessa Anderson of Magnolia, Kaylee Hagan of River and Ava Wohnhas of River. Second Team Class 2A was Mallory McDiffitt of Magnolia and Mallorie Maddy of River.